Florida Entrepreneurs' Resource
Home arrow Getting Started arrow Business Form Comparison Table
Business Form Comparison Table PDF Print E-mail
Written by Mark Hankins   
Jun 21, 2007 at 09:05 AM

Choosing among business formats can be bewildering. Here's a table that helps you know what your options will mean in practice. Keep in mind that while corporations default to being C Corporations and must make an active choice in order to be S Corporations, LLCs may choose among four tax treatments, with sole proprietorship and partnership treatment available in addition to the two treatments available to corporations.

 

Entity Types Annual Renewal (UBR) FeeName Exclu-sivityCorporate FormalitiesTax CharacteristicsTypical UseGotchas
C Corporations$150YesMinutes of Organizational Meeting, Bylaws, Annual Board of Directors MeetingsPays Own Income Tax on Gains at Graduated Rates, any Losses are “trapped” inside, and any dividends are taxable to OwnersLarge Businesses, Publicly-traded Businesses,Small Businesses Intending to Grow by Retaining Capital for purposes of ExpansionProfits will be taxed at the Entity Level and Shareholder Level (often misleadingly-termed “double taxation”—it’s less than double), Losses will be “trapped” inside the entity as “carryforwards” to offset future profits (and will expire at a future time if unused)
S Corporations$150YesMinutes of Organizational Meeting, Bylaws, Annual Board of Directors MeetingsGains or Losses Pass Thru to Owner(s)Small Businesses (under $5 million) wishing to minimize entity-level taxPotential for “phantom income” to owners (profits not paid out still show up on 1040), lack of flexibility in capital structure: ownership percentage fixes gain percentage and loss percentage of any shareholder, additionally all owners must be U.S. persons
LLC Sole Proprietorship$50Yes, but due to change in the law, older LLCs with the same name can be found, valid and existing on the state's recordsOperating Agreement not neededGains or Losses Pass Thru to OwnerIndividual wishing to minimize tax-related paperwork (files Schedule C with 1040 form), or needing entity simply for Workers’ Comp Insurance exemption purposesNo separation between business and personal tax picture – since both business and personal taxes are on same return, an audit of one side can easily “jump the fence” and involve issues on the other side
LLC Partnership$50Yes - Same as aboveOperating AgreementGains or Losses Pass Thru to OwnersBusiness having multiple owners but wishing to minimize corporate formalities, or having stakeholders who should be treated differently for tax purposes (e.g. money partner, working partner, partner contributing property)Using true “partnership accounting principles” rather than the S Corp’s “partnership in a straitjacket” adds complexity. Must follow IRS “substantial economic effect” rules if ownership interests vary from profit and loss interests.
LLC S Corporation$50Yes - Same as aboveOperating AgreementGains or Losses Pass Thru to Owner(s)Business having multiple owners but wishing to minimize corporate formalities, but wanting to pay some money out as salary to shareholders while paying the rest as dividends (not subject to social security and medicare tax)If too much of what is paid out to owners is classified as dividends and salary is clearly nominal (tiny by comparison), IRS may recharacterize some dividends as salary, resulting in additional tax and penalties
LLC C Corporation$50Yes, Same as aboveOperating AgreementPays Own Income Tax on Gains at Graduated Rates, any Losses are “trapped” inside, and any dividends are taxable to OwnersBusinesses wishing to minimize corporate formalities while retaining earnings & profits for planned future growth. Profits will be taxed at the Entity Level and Shareholder Level (often misleadingly-termed “double taxation”—it’s less than double), Losses will be “trapped” inside the entity as “carryforwards” to offset future profits (and will expire at a future time if unused)

User Comments

Please login or register to add comments

Last Updated ( Jan 29, 2008 at 03:04 PM )
Polls
How Did You Find the Florida Entrepreneurs' Resource?
  
Latest News
Who's Online
We have 24 guests online